I agree, you footing the shipping bill is unreasonable, especially when he didn't use actual pictures of the actual item.

Looks like filing the claim worked.

"We have closed your A-to-z Guarantee claim for this order because the seller has issued a refund in the amount of $27.95 on July 16, 2014:"

I am glad he decided to not make me go through any more hassle in regards to this, I just hate that it had to come to me filing that claim.
I hate to feel like I am being a dick to anybody, but I really did not ask much of the guy, I stayed professional throughout the whole thing, which was tough to do because I was pissed that I got burned, and that he seemed to not want to accept any responsibility.

Now, sell me the part, I'll fix it up real nice and attempt to sell it to him for 3X'* as much. Including skunk juice.