1.9 Rockers - Is it worth the cost ??
Originally Posted by Sol
News to me. That'* a nice inexpensive option to take in to consideration.
Without the roller tips, I wouldn't think it is wise to run with OR pushrods because you would need the extra cooling of oil flow due to tip friction that the stock pushrods offer.
just a small question,..... that "25hp" gain... does that also take into account the mods you've already done... cause that would be a HUGE improvement in cam specs over what you've got right now... added to what you've already got... I would think you'd get more then just "25hp" outta going to 1.9 rockers
.255 Intake (.408" valve lift stock, .485" w/1.9 rockers)
.258 Exhaust (.413" valve lift stock, .490" w/1.9 rockers)
However, take a look at this dyno sheet from a decently modded '02 GTP:
Blue line is aftermarket cam, red line is stock, green line is 1.9 rockers:

In his fairly heavily modded car the rockers didn't even make much difference. I have found they make 10-15whp on just about every application, no matter how modded. And the cam gains there are promising, however you have to remember that a cam is a LOT more work and definately requires at least different valvesprings, but the pushrods really should be replaced as well. I would recommend a cam for anyone who wants to get really serious, but based on what I have gathered from his posts, silverbullet isn't looking for a race car, and I don't think I would tear into a low miles engine like that either. IMO rockers are perfect for what he wants.
Shawn
Level 1(shown in red) - 221 wheel horsepower, 276 crank horsepower
First we installed an SLP cold air induction system, INTENSE™ 3.40" supercharger pulley, Gatorback supercharger belt, INTENSE™ 180 degree thermostat and Autolite 605 (one heat range colder) spark plugs. Net gains were 29 wheel horsepower, which is about 36 crank horsepower.
Level 2(shown in blue) - 244 wheel horsepower, 305 crank horsepower
Next we added 1.90:1 INTENSE™ Third Gen Full Roller Rocker Arms with no other changes. Net gains were 23 wheel horsepower, which is about 29 crank horsepower.
First we installed an SLP cold air induction system, INTENSE™ 3.40" supercharger pulley, Gatorback supercharger belt, INTENSE™ 180 degree thermostat and Autolite 605 (one heat range colder) spark plugs. Net gains were 29 wheel horsepower, which is about 36 crank horsepower.
Level 2(shown in blue) - 244 wheel horsepower, 305 crank horsepower
Next we added 1.90:1 INTENSE™ Third Gen Full Roller Rocker Arms with no other changes. Net gains were 23 wheel horsepower, which is about 29 crank horsepower.
I just may give the I-Win'* a go......even if you say it'* only worth 12 hp, I'm optimistic that I may get a little more.
Intense'* claims are based off of Rogue'* Dyno'*....
I've driven his car with rockers, it was nice, made smellbirds go faster nicely as well.
However a nice set of heads and a cam would be very beneficial....
I've driven his car with rockers, it was nice, made smellbirds go faster nicely as well.
However a nice set of heads and a cam would be very beneficial....
Originally Posted by Sol
How do you end up losing torque from that? That right there turns me away.
Shawn
Sol wrote:
How do you end up losing torque from that? That right there turns me away.
They claim that the torque difference is due to swapping out motor mounts at the same time I guess...
How do you end up losing torque from that? That right there turns me away.
They claim that the torque difference is due to swapping out motor mounts at the same time I guess...
Can anyone else with 1.9 rockers step in and give us their experience with the 1.9 rocker swap with regard to torque loss of low rpm <3000 rpm. :?
An actual loss of low end torque is not good for everyday driving. Might be OK for racing where the engine is always up over 3000. rpm.
Of course, our cars are torque beasts already....and it could help traction, not to mention trani life (but that'* a stretch).
There is good reason why true racers install a 3000 rpm stall torque converter.
Here is a whole page about the 3 dyno pulls. That way you can make your own conclusion.
http://www.3800performance.com/cc_xt...7_cam_dyno.htm
I've never noticed a torque loss and I've done quite a few rocker swaps, but thats probably because they have so much torque to begin with. The torque loss isn't noticable if there is one.
I don't know how to explain it other than every car is different, because the car that did that dyno had INTENSE rocker arms on it. I know this because there was a big post about it on ClubGP. People were getting pissed at INTENSE for something, stealing a pic or something stupid like that, and Luan got all pissed off and said that was it, he was done with intense parts and he was pulling them all out of his car. So he took out all the intense parts (rocker arms being one of those things) and replaced them with other parts, in this case he installed a cam instead of Intense'* rockers. But he did have previous conflicts with INTENSE that I don't want to get into right now, so I can almost understand why he did that.
Shawn
http://www.3800performance.com/cc_xt...7_cam_dyno.htm
I've never noticed a torque loss and I've done quite a few rocker swaps, but thats probably because they have so much torque to begin with. The torque loss isn't noticable if there is one.
Good info Shawn. So how do you explain INTENSE'* claim of 23 whp with just the 1.9 rockers.
I just may give the I-Win'* a go......even if you say it'* only worth 12 hp, I'm optimistic that I may get a little more.
I just may give the I-Win'* a go......even if you say it'* only worth 12 hp, I'm optimistic that I may get a little more.
Shawn
I don't know how to explain it other than every car is different, because the car that did that dyno had INTENSE rocker arms on it.
Lift is lift.
The only difference between the two brands of rockers is the friction reducing rollers and a slight weight advantage.
In the long run you'll wish you had the lighter, roller rockers. They'll last longer, run smoother, and aren't cutting corners. I know your gonna keep that car a long time, and wanna keep building her up, so think about the future. Why not hold off till you can get what you want?



