oil filters. fram = bad. good=?
I used Fram all the time back in the 80’* & 90’* (Delco & Purolator now).
IIRC - In the mid 80’* Consumer Reports did an evaluation / bench testing of oil filers in which Fram was rated one of the best.
Just goes to show that things can change.
IIRC - In the mid 80’* Consumer Reports did an evaluation / bench testing of oil filers in which Fram was rated one of the best.
Just goes to show that things can change.
Senior Member
True Car Nut
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 9,130
Likes: 0
From: Farmington, Minnesota =MWBF '05 SURVIVOR= =CEBF '06 SURVIVOR= =August '06 COTM=

Originally Posted by willwren
Originally Posted by LakevilleSSEi
The K&N'* to me are just another name, and I don't care for K&N'* $10 price tag, prolly just paying for the name. Mobil 1 I don't know much about them, ran them on my last 2 bonne'* with no problems, didn't notice anything special I don't recall for the close to $10 price tag also.
I run K&N. Why? Because even after 6000 miles on Mobil1 without changing the filter, my oil was cleaner (based on 2 UOA'*) than 3000 miles on Dino Juice and a PureOne filter.
My thing about the Amsoil that I run, is the fact that I go longer on a service interval. Changing my oil every 3k, at 3 galllons and a filter per change, times five to make it to my 15K mark (under a severe service)....Costs me more than the one time I change with Amsoil.
Anyways, difference I noticed was cold starting ability, OP change, and noise amount from the engine. Just because when I used the Mobil 1 and a K&N filter on a bonne a few times and didn't care for it doesn't mean I need to smacked in the face with a brick or something for having a preference and opinion.
Guest
Posts: n/a
Enough of the Bickering from everyone...
Answer to the question... Keeping in mind that Marik is not a rich man and chances are he won't be spending the $$$ on a K & N or Amsoil...
Marik, The PF47 AC Delco, The Wix, The Puralator the Havoline filter among several others will be fine for your car bud..
And again, if you are ever out this way I have several filters you can have.. I stock up on the suckers..
__________________
Best Car Insurance | Auto Protection Today | FREE Trade-In Quote
Answer to the question... Keeping in mind that Marik is not a rich man and chances are he won't be spending the $$$ on a K & N or Amsoil...
Marik, The PF47 AC Delco, The Wix, The Puralator the Havoline filter among several others will be fine for your car bud..
And again, if you are ever out this way I have several filters you can have.. I stock up on the suckers..
__________________
Best Car Insurance | Auto Protection Today | FREE Trade-In Quote
Originally Posted by willwren
I run K&N. Why? Because even after 6000 miles on Mobil1 without changing the filter, my oil was cleaner (based on 2 UOA'*) than 3000 miles on Dino Juice and a PureOne filter.
Also do not lump all Frams in the same category. The Tough Guard is a decent filter however you can get the same protection at less cost with Wix or Purolator.
Mark:
PEP Boys has some decent sales on oil and filters. last summer I picked up two free oil changes using Valvoline oil and filters, after rebates, and 6 Qts of Valvoline for $4.00 after rebate. Check them out.
Originally Posted by LakevilleSSEi
Originally Posted by willwren
Originally Posted by LakevilleSSEi
The K&N'* to me are just another name, and I don't care for K&N'* $10 price tag, prolly just paying for the name. Mobil 1 I don't know much about them, ran them on my last 2 bonne'* with no problems, didn't notice anything special I don't recall for the close to $10 price tag also.
I run K&N. Why? Because even after 6000 miles on Mobil1 without changing the filter, my oil was cleaner (based on 2 UOA'*) than 3000 miles on Dino Juice and a PureOne filter.
My thing about the Amsoil that I run, is the fact that I go longer on a service interval. Changing my oil every 3k, at 3 galllons and a filter per change, times five to make it to my 15K mark (under a severe service)....Costs me more than the one time I change with Amsoil.
Anyways, difference I noticed was cold starting ability, OP change, and noise amount from the engine. Just because when I used the Mobil 1 and a K&N filter on a bonne a few times and didn't care for it doesn't mean I need to smacked in the face with a brick or something for having a preference and opinion.
Your truck has no bearing (due to oil capacity) on your statements here or on the questions asked.
Smacked in the face? I would expect someone with all that amsoil in his signature to either not bash the competition, or stay out of the topic altogether other than 'see what I can offer'. Please remember what we expect of our vendors here.
Head to head, I doubt amsoil lubricants or filters are any better than any other premium offer out there.
Senior Member
Posts like a Northstar
Joined: Aug 2007
Posts: 620
Likes: 0
From: Ladysmith B.C. Canada

I hate to beat this to death (any more than it has already
) However, I've seen many posts saying that Fram= EVIL (more or less). That there are plastic parts, cardboard parts, etc. used in the making of Fram oil filters.
So, today I was cleaning up my shop and found an old Fram oil filter and decided to cut it open and see what was really in there.
NO plastic
NO cardboard
Just metal, paper filter element and a silicone rubber gasket. Identical to the innards of the expensive filters that I use in my airplane (except smaller).



No plastic insert here, just metal.


So, today I was cleaning up my shop and found an old Fram oil filter and decided to cut it open and see what was really in there.
NO plastic
NO cardboard
Just metal, paper filter element and a silicone rubber gasket. Identical to the innards of the expensive filters that I use in my airplane (except smaller).



No plastic insert here, just metal.


Senior Member
Posts like a Northstar
Joined: Aug 2007
Posts: 620
Likes: 0
From: Ladysmith B.C. Canada

Originally Posted by calaeb0896
i always use mobil 1 oil filters and i haven't had any problems.
Well that wasn't really the point of my post. I just can't see anything wrong with the way the Fram filter is built. I'm wondering if maybe the ones we get in Canada are made different than the ones being complained about.


