Engine Trouble need direction
#12
Senior Member
Posts like a Northstar
Use which coolant
I checked the labels on DexCool and the Mixes With Any Type coolants and they have the same 4 ingredients. There isn't any difference anymore that I can tell.Even the label on the front of the Mixes type says 5 years and 150,000 miles just like the DexCool.
#13
Junior Member
Posts like a V-Tak
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: St.Louis area
Posts: 25
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
well I hate dex cool just because of the rumors. I didn't find the torque specs on the tech info . I'm taking a big chance on my engine with all the money I've spent on parts. I want to do it right.
#14
Senior Member
True Car Nut
Click on: Techinfo, then click on: Specifications and General Information, then click on: Assembly Torque Specs for 87-99 Bonnevilles, under which you will find:
Intake Manifold________________________Ft/Lbs
87-90 Vin 3 (in sequence)..............47
87-90 Vin C (twice, in sequence).......88 (In/Lbs)
Throttle body bolts....................20
91-99 (except 95-97 Vin 1 and K).......89 (In/Lbs, twice, in sequence)
1995 Vin K (twice, in sequence)........89 (In/Lbs)
96-97 Vin K (in sequence)..............11
95-99 Vin 1............................11 and
It is 11 ft-lbs for the LIM, and 7.5 ft-lbs (89 inch-lb) for the UIM.
For throttle body nuts on 6mm studs set into plastic upper intake manifolds, use 7.5 ft-lb.
The tightening sequence starts at the center of the piece, and alternates side to side to the ends. Use blue threadlocker on the bolts for the LIM and the UIM.
Intake Manifold________________________Ft/Lbs
87-90 Vin 3 (in sequence)..............47
87-90 Vin C (twice, in sequence).......88 (In/Lbs)
Throttle body bolts....................20
91-99 (except 95-97 Vin 1 and K).......89 (In/Lbs, twice, in sequence)
1995 Vin K (twice, in sequence)........89 (In/Lbs)
96-97 Vin K (in sequence)..............11
95-99 Vin 1............................11 and
It is 11 ft-lbs for the LIM, and 7.5 ft-lbs (89 inch-lb) for the UIM.
For throttle body nuts on 6mm studs set into plastic upper intake manifolds, use 7.5 ft-lb.
The tightening sequence starts at the center of the piece, and alternates side to side to the ends. Use blue threadlocker on the bolts for the LIM and the UIM.
#15
Senior Member
True Car Nut
Re: Use which coolant
Originally Posted by imidazol
I checked the labels on DexCool and the Mixes With Any Type coolants and they have the same 4 ingredients. There isn't any difference anymore that I can tell.Even the label on the front of the Mixes type says 5 years and 150,000 miles just like the DexCool.
An identical list of (major) ingredients does not prove that two products are the same or that they are compatible. There could be significant differences in the proportions of ingredients, in the methods of formulation, and there could be proprietary ingredients in the additive packages that are NOT listed on the label. Consider that a label of major ingredients: engine, transmission, wheels, seats, would be identical for a Mercedes and for a Daewoo - they are not the same.
I maintain that unless we know for absolute certain that Dex-Cool has changed its formulation and that the new formulation is compatible with other coolants and that it will not damage engine gaskets when it gets old or is exposed to air, then we should not recommend its use when safe alternatives are available.
#17
Senior Member
Posts like a Northstar
Re: Use which coolant
Originally Posted by bill buttermore
When you go to Prestone.com, you will see prominently displayed "compatible with any coolant" for several of the different types of coolant sold by Prestone, but NOT for Dex-Cool. Many people have been confused by "compatible with Dex-cool" labels on yellow-colored long life (mixes with any color) coolant, thinking that compatible with Dex cool means that it is a new formulation of Dex-Cool. It is not. Dex-Cool sold by Texaco Havoline and by Prestone is orange colored stuff in a silver bottle that is the patented GM formula that many believe has caused so much engine damage.
An identical list of (major) ingredients does not prove that two products are the same or that they are compatible. that Dex-Cool has changed its formulation and that the new formulation is compatible with other coolants and that it will not damage engine gaskets when it gets old or is exposed to air, then we should not recommend its use when safe alternatives are available.
An identical list of (major) ingredients does not prove that two products are the same or that they are compatible. that Dex-Cool has changed its formulation and that the new formulation is compatible with other coolants and that it will not damage engine gaskets when it gets old or is exposed to air, then we should not recommend its use when safe alternatives are available.
Other other hand if one doesn't feel comfortable recommending DexCool, changed at proper early intervals of 30,000 miles/two years or less, and with the radiator checked to be sure it'* kept full along with the overflow reservoir and the heater core kept free of air bubbles then we shouldn't recommend the Mixes with all Types either. The bottle labels are required to show active ingredients. Another brand shows a proprietary additive on their label because they're required but they don't disclose what it is, e.g. If there were more to the DexCool then it would be disclosed on the DexCool bottle and on the Mixes with all Types bottle.
The hexanoate (ester?) is questioned by some and was discussed in the court testimony as potentially a problem with plastic seals. It is a corrosion inhibitor but also has a plasticizer characteristic and can interact to soften plastics such as the 6/6 seal That same chemical is in the Mixes with all Types.
Early DexCool reported used an oxidation inhibitor (preservative) that was changed and replaced with a more costly ingredient (funny how companies choose the cheaper solution such as MTBE). I am not sure if this is related to the earlier chemical or not. I need to do some rereading.
It looks like both are the same.
After reading the recent postings, although not by chemists, by people in the radiator/coolant business and selected quotes from testimony in the various cases against DexCool/GM, I am considering putting pure green stuff into my 03. I'll leave the DexCool in the 98.
#18
Junior Member
Posts like a V-Tak
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: St.Louis area
Posts: 25
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
should I use rtv on any of the gaskets, I've heard in the corners of LIM, and maybe a small bead. Also, I'm changing the plugs and wires. In your opinions what kind should I get.
#19
Senior Member
True Car Nut
Originally Posted by jberg6
should I use rtv on any of the gaskets, I've heard in the corners of LIM, and maybe a small bead. Also, I'm changing the plugs and wires. In your opinions what kind should I get.
#20
Senior Member
True Car Nut
Re: Use which coolant
Originally Posted by imidazol
...snip...
It looks like both are the same.
It looks like both are the same.
Why would you choose to use Dex, when you could choose to use a product with no known history of problems? What advantages does it provide that are worth the risks of it damaging your engine?
BTW, here in central Iowa, I have not seen the older phosphated green coolant for sale for about two years now.