bad safety (long read)
#1
Senior Member
Posts like a Corvette
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada
Posts: 1,445
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
bad safety (long read)
Looks like I may have fallen victim to a falsified safety inspection here.
Here in Manitoba, before ANY vehicle is transferred between two parties it must hold a valid safety certification. All insurance is public (super cheap here) and this safety MUST be presented when the car is insured.
So I was driving down the road and the brake light comes on and that chime started. I quickly went home and I felt my brakes beginning to fail. It was not a comfortable drive home. Sure enough when I popped the hood my master cylinder was empty. Turns out that the brake line going to the rear of the car was completely rusted through and gave way. When my respectable mechanic had the tires off, he noticed the pads were PAPER thin, rotors were beat up beyond repair, and rust on the right brake caliper and assembly was causing it to not function propery and uneven brake wear.
Now heres the real kicker. Not 700km'* ago this car passed a safety inspection and all the components above were indicated as being "safe". There was not even an advisory issued for anything above. There is no way, that in 700km could a brake line rust to the point of failure, rotors damaged, pads paper thin, and rusty calipers could occur.
How do you think I should pursue this? I have the safety sheet with all the information of the place and person that issued the document. I have the old parts as evidence, and my mechanic who told me there was no way in hell this would have passed a safety inspection. Not only that, but I could have been seriously injured as the brakes went out when I was driving.
BTW, the place I brought it is just awesome. The mechanic there spent 15 minutes explaining to me what had gone wrong, what was done, and he even looked over the safety sheet and showed me how they measured brake wear, the criteria certain things need to meet, etc. He has agreed to back me up if needed. First I think I'm going to go talk to the place that issued this and see what they will do for me. If they laugh at me and send me off I'm going to go straight to the BBB and any other organization I can. I'll let them know that I will as well...
Sorry for the huge post, but what should I do in this situation?
Here in Manitoba, before ANY vehicle is transferred between two parties it must hold a valid safety certification. All insurance is public (super cheap here) and this safety MUST be presented when the car is insured.
So I was driving down the road and the brake light comes on and that chime started. I quickly went home and I felt my brakes beginning to fail. It was not a comfortable drive home. Sure enough when I popped the hood my master cylinder was empty. Turns out that the brake line going to the rear of the car was completely rusted through and gave way. When my respectable mechanic had the tires off, he noticed the pads were PAPER thin, rotors were beat up beyond repair, and rust on the right brake caliper and assembly was causing it to not function propery and uneven brake wear.
Now heres the real kicker. Not 700km'* ago this car passed a safety inspection and all the components above were indicated as being "safe". There was not even an advisory issued for anything above. There is no way, that in 700km could a brake line rust to the point of failure, rotors damaged, pads paper thin, and rusty calipers could occur.
How do you think I should pursue this? I have the safety sheet with all the information of the place and person that issued the document. I have the old parts as evidence, and my mechanic who told me there was no way in hell this would have passed a safety inspection. Not only that, but I could have been seriously injured as the brakes went out when I was driving.
BTW, the place I brought it is just awesome. The mechanic there spent 15 minutes explaining to me what had gone wrong, what was done, and he even looked over the safety sheet and showed me how they measured brake wear, the criteria certain things need to meet, etc. He has agreed to back me up if needed. First I think I'm going to go talk to the place that issued this and see what they will do for me. If they laugh at me and send me off I'm going to go straight to the BBB and any other organization I can. I'll let them know that I will as well...
Sorry for the huge post, but what should I do in this situation?
#2
Senior Member
True Car Nut
Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: Rochester, NY (college)
Posts: 6,182
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I dont have a lot of advice, BUT this place you bought it from, if they had a mechanic why didn't they check over the car before they sold it??
#3
Senior Member
True Car Nut
yeah that is pretty bad, they dont have saftey or emissions or anything here, straight pipe with a blown headgasket, missing brake pads not a problem.
I would go back to the dealer WITH THE BRAKE PADS and show them.
I would go back to the dealer WITH THE BRAKE PADS and show them.
#4
Senior Member
True Car Nut
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: Groton, CT _NEBF 05, 06, 07_
Posts: 2,703
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: bad safety (long read)
Originally Posted by captainmiller
I'm going to go straight to the BBB and any other organization I can. I'll let them know that I will as well..
Sorry for the huge post, but what should I do in this situation?
Sorry for the huge post, but what should I do in this situation?
#5
DINOSAURUS BOOSTUS
Expert Gearhead
Cap'n... Place A issued the safety report and Dealer B sold you the car?
Place A has some answering to do then. Your plan of action sounds good, since place A issued the report they are the responsible party.
Place A has some answering to do then. Your plan of action sounds good, since place A issued the report they are the responsible party.
#8
Senior Member
Posts like a Northstar
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Purgatory
Posts: 533
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
As I understand it; the inspection is required by the government. There must be a government agency to report this to. My sense of humor ends when scammers start messing with peoples lives.
#9
Senior Member
Posts like a Turbo
Join Date: May 2005
Location: Fredericton, New Brunswick.
Posts: 380
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
The inspecton station could face a fine, plus losses of their liscences. Make sure you take pictures, note the location and time, and mileage the brakes failed. Note the mechanic who inspected and passed the car, and provide the inspection slip as well.
I'd definitly take it to the department of motor vehicles, insurance companies of theirs, and whomever else you can find, if the mechanic shrugs you off.
I'd definitly take it to the department of motor vehicles, insurance companies of theirs, and whomever else you can find, if the mechanic shrugs you off.
#10
Senior Member
Expert Gearhead
If the Province of Manitoba is anything like the Province of Ontario in regards to Safety Certification, the notice is only valid for an certain amount of time. I would contact the place that did the original safety, as well as the findings from the place you went to afterwards, and compare the two documents, I would bring that to the Ministry of Transportation.
Its not in the governments interest to have "certified" shops giving away Safety certificates.
Time is crucial here.
To bad Ontario doesnt have public insurance
Its not in the governments interest to have "certified" shops giving away Safety certificates.
Time is crucial here.
To bad Ontario doesnt have public insurance