View Poll Results: WHich one is better and why???
Voters: 24. You may not vote on this poll
Which is better and why?
#12
Senior Member
Posts like a Corvette
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: San Diego, CA
Posts: 1,451
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Gutted air box, at least in California. And hope the smog inspector isn't shrewd.
I looked it up last night, and get this...
No engine or tranny mod is legal for road use in California UNLESS it is on the list of SPECIFICALLY APPROVED mods by CARB (California Air Resource Board).
So, on ANY Bonneville (or LeSabre), no aftermarket intake is legal. You would fail visual smog inspection. Even putting a K&N rectangular filter in your stock airbox is not legal in CA.
Also, high-flow cats, high-flow mufflers, headers, aftermarket fuel delivery components, throttles or plates, or aftermarket PCM'* are not legal on any Bonneville (or LeSabre) for road use in California.
Not only that, but replacement engines (for any road use car) must be the same year or newer, and replacement transmissions are NOT ALLOWED FOR ANY ROAD USE CAR.
There'* lots of mods on the approved list for Nissans, Hondas, Toyotas, and various light trucks, but almost nothing for my dear LeSabre.
I looked it up last night, and get this...
No engine or tranny mod is legal for road use in California UNLESS it is on the list of SPECIFICALLY APPROVED mods by CARB (California Air Resource Board).
So, on ANY Bonneville (or LeSabre), no aftermarket intake is legal. You would fail visual smog inspection. Even putting a K&N rectangular filter in your stock airbox is not legal in CA.
Also, high-flow cats, high-flow mufflers, headers, aftermarket fuel delivery components, throttles or plates, or aftermarket PCM'* are not legal on any Bonneville (or LeSabre) for road use in California.
Not only that, but replacement engines (for any road use car) must be the same year or newer, and replacement transmissions are NOT ALLOWED FOR ANY ROAD USE CAR.
There'* lots of mods on the approved list for Nissans, Hondas, Toyotas, and various light trucks, but almost nothing for my dear LeSabre.
#13
Senior Member
Posts like a Camaro
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: Aurora, Illinois
Posts: 922
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I've never ran a gutted airbox but ive had my INTENSE FWI on since September and it was a very straight forward install. Seeing as the FWI is drawing air from outside the engine bay and right above the airdam/splash guard i would assume your getting a colder air charge in the engine since your starting with cooler air to begin with. My only complaint about the FWI is pretty minor, but starting it on cold days sounds like i've got a shop-vac in my wheel well.
#15
DINOSAURUS BOOSTUS
Expert Gearhead
No vote here, instead..my ramblings to think over.
I'm probablly the only nut that ran a gutted airbox wtih a 3.2" pulley.
From ATV experience (including 4 stroke) the idea is to have a large storehouse of air right in front of the intake. This is an airbox.. with a K&N air filter it is a large filtering surface. The inlet of the airbox once gutted exceeds the size of the FWI tubing. As for cold.. The air is coming from in back of the headlight to the side of the radiator.
The FWI on the other hand.. is in the fender, the tubing is much longer than the total length of the gutted airbox. Large filtering capacity and a long tube. The FWI has the ability in hot climates and summertime to better pick up heat from the road when the pavement is hotter than the general air temperature. The tubing promotes more laminar flow. Can the MAF screen be taken out with this laminar flow? I personally haven't tried yet.
I have noticed one thing running the FWI, it'* louder all the time. Sounds worse on cold start up, and more whine on top end. Sound level isn't my goal, HP is.... There are factual numbers that say the FWI is better.. I haven't looked for them though.
I'm probablly the only nut that ran a gutted airbox wtih a 3.2" pulley.
From ATV experience (including 4 stroke) the idea is to have a large storehouse of air right in front of the intake. This is an airbox.. with a K&N air filter it is a large filtering surface. The inlet of the airbox once gutted exceeds the size of the FWI tubing. As for cold.. The air is coming from in back of the headlight to the side of the radiator.
The FWI on the other hand.. is in the fender, the tubing is much longer than the total length of the gutted airbox. Large filtering capacity and a long tube. The FWI has the ability in hot climates and summertime to better pick up heat from the road when the pavement is hotter than the general air temperature. The tubing promotes more laminar flow. Can the MAF screen be taken out with this laminar flow? I personally haven't tried yet.
I have noticed one thing running the FWI, it'* louder all the time. Sounds worse on cold start up, and more whine on top end. Sound level isn't my goal, HP is.... There are factual numbers that say the FWI is better.. I haven't looked for them though.
#16
Junior Member
Posts like a Ricer Type-R
Originally Posted by agrazela
Gutted air box, at least in California. And hope the smog inspector isn't shrewd.
I looked it up last night, and get this...
No engine or tranny mod is legal for road use in California UNLESS it is on the list of SPECIFICALLY APPROVED mods by CARB (California Air Resource Board).
So, on ANY Bonneville (or LeSabre), no aftermarket intake is legal. You would fail visual smog inspection. Even putting a K&N rectangular filter in your stock airbox is not legal in CA.
Also, high-flow cats, high-flow mufflers, headers, aftermarket fuel delivery components, throttles or plates, or aftermarket PCM'* are not legal on any Bonneville (or LeSabre) for road use in California.
Not only that, but replacement engines (for any road use car) must be the same year or newer, and replacement transmissions are NOT ALLOWED FOR ANY ROAD USE CAR.
There'* lots of mods on the approved list for Nissans, Hondas, Toyotas, and various light trucks, but almost nothing for my dear LeSabre.
I looked it up last night, and get this...
No engine or tranny mod is legal for road use in California UNLESS it is on the list of SPECIFICALLY APPROVED mods by CARB (California Air Resource Board).
So, on ANY Bonneville (or LeSabre), no aftermarket intake is legal. You would fail visual smog inspection. Even putting a K&N rectangular filter in your stock airbox is not legal in CA.
Also, high-flow cats, high-flow mufflers, headers, aftermarket fuel delivery components, throttles or plates, or aftermarket PCM'* are not legal on any Bonneville (or LeSabre) for road use in California.
Not only that, but replacement engines (for any road use car) must be the same year or newer, and replacement transmissions are NOT ALLOWED FOR ANY ROAD USE CAR.
There'* lots of mods on the approved list for Nissans, Hondas, Toyotas, and various light trucks, but almost nothing for my dear LeSabre.
Besides, this is why you keep your stock airbox to convert back before inspection.
#17
Senior Member
True Car Nut
Join Date: Sep 2004
Location: Fitchburg Ma _ToastedRice_
Posts: 6,837
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
i agree with Bill, there are many modifications that fail inspection in many states, many states clearly state that ANY exhaust modification that does not comply with ALL OEM specifications are grounds for inspection failure.. How many cars/trucks do you see on the road with loud pipes? sure, the cops ticket the ricers, the stupids, and the super loud exhausts occasionally, but that is about all there is to worry about
#18
Senior Member
Posts like a Corvette
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: San Diego, CA
Posts: 1,451
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I'll probably go, at most, with a modified airbox/K&N, keeping an unmodified/ACDelco around for smog inspection time.
I'm a bit paranoid about this crap, because my 1993 Dakota failed two consecutive smog inspections (the first solely for visual...cracked PCV tube! The second for bad O2 sensor), and is now permanently branded a "Gross Polluter" by CA DMV. This effectively makes the truck unsellable to anyone (north of the border) who has access to Carfax.
I'll be darned if I'm letting that happen to me LeSabres!
I'm a bit paranoid about this crap, because my 1993 Dakota failed two consecutive smog inspections (the first solely for visual...cracked PCV tube! The second for bad O2 sensor), and is now permanently branded a "Gross Polluter" by CA DMV. This effectively makes the truck unsellable to anyone (north of the border) who has access to Carfax.
I'll be darned if I'm letting that happen to me LeSabres!
#19
Senior Member
True Car Nut
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Westerville, Ohio 2000 Black SSEi
Posts: 6,127
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
The cold startup "shopvac" sounds is due to the Idle Air controller (IAC) functioning properly to help get the motor up to heat. It is louder because the sound is not baffled anymore by the stock airbox.
With a 7 inch cone in an SLP CAI I had 2 degree of KR back in the day and after switching to a 9" FWI it was instantly gone, no other changes, same day, same ambient temps and conditions. At speed air is bouncing off your radiator so fast into the bumperwell that air temps picked up by the intake air are almost always ambient or very close. At idle the air temps may be warmer due to being so close to asphalt heat, but this is rapidly diminished as speed increases with forward movement.
With a 7 inch cone in an SLP CAI I had 2 degree of KR back in the day and after switching to a 9" FWI it was instantly gone, no other changes, same day, same ambient temps and conditions. At speed air is bouncing off your radiator so fast into the bumperwell that air temps picked up by the intake air are almost always ambient or very close. At idle the air temps may be warmer due to being so close to asphalt heat, but this is rapidly diminished as speed increases with forward movement.