Another modern singer that I like to play when I'm with a girl is Sarah McClaughlen (not sure how to spell her last name).
Ratmfan2118 is right, Yes, Barry White -how could we forget about him.
And on those Conservative Catholic/Christian'*, I know what you're saying -I went to a private Catholic school myself, and my family attends the old Latin Mass every Sunday. The local people (girls especially) can't believe how easygoing (if that'* how you'd describe me) I am compared to all the rest of my family and cousin. My family calls me the black sheep of the family, not in a real bad way though, as we all get along and they accept my lifestyle (I don't go break laws, just I live a bit wilder than I was brought up to be).