Anything by Celine Dion especially her older stuff, Josh Groban, Micheal Bolton
Amy Lee and Seether "Broken"
Hinder "Lips of an Angel"
Avril Lavigne "I'm With You"
Bob Seger "We've Got Tonight"
Bon Jovi " I'll Be There for You" (played at my wedding)
Bryan Adams "Everything I Do" "Heaven"
Santana and Chad Kroger " Into the Night"
Dan Hill "Sometimes When we Touch"
Eric Clapton "Tears in Heaven"
Garth Brooks " If Tomorrow Never Comes"
Rascal Flatts " What Hurts the Most"
Those ones are the sappy ones
If you like a little bit heavier (not breathing)
Good Charlotte "I Don't Want to Be in Love"
Flo' Rida "Elevator"
Guns and Roses "Sweet Child of Mine"
Whitesnake " Fool For Your Lovin' "
Velvet Revolver " Fall to Pieces"
Van Halen "Dreams"
Timbaland "The Way I Are"
Hedley "321" or whatever you prefer
Three Doors Down" Here with You"
Johnny Cash "Hurt"
Sheryl Crow and Kid Rock "Picture"
Korn "Coming Undone"
Three Days Grace " Never Too Late"
Saliva "Rest In Pieces"
If you are going to make a romantic CD I hope it is for a girl, and if it is for a girl, make sure it is music she likes, or you will not get anywhere with her, and if this CD is for a guy, then again you need to know what he likes. But seeing as I am not a guy, I can't help you in that department.