Karma for comparing the new Eclipse to the Grand National.
But really, insurance companies do this kind of crap all the time. My wife was rear ended in her new GA. We got an estimate from the largest, busiest shop in town, then the insurance sent us a check for $250 less citing their records indicate it should be less, SITE UNSEEN OF THE CAR. They really had no idea of what was actually damaged. After an angry call from me, they said if the amount was confirmed, the extra money would be sent to the shop to guarantee they did the repair. So I just buffed out the scratchs, leaving cracks only seen from the under side. The shop would have replaced the bumper cover and painted it. We put the money in the bank.