3 white guys
#1
Senior Member
True Car Nut
Thread Starter
3 white guys
Three white men were taken captive by a hostile Indian tribe. The chieftain was willing to let them go so he took them to a tepee, where there was no light. He put one head band on each of their heads (he had 3 white and 2 red - so 2 head bands were not used - captives were informed about these numbers). Then they went out in a queue so that each man saw the head-band of those standing in front of himself (the first one did not see any head band, the second one saw the first one'* head band, and the third one saw the head bands of the two others). If somebody said the colour of his head-band, they all would be free. After a quiet while one of them (the one in front who could not see any of the others) said: "My head-band is ...".
What colour was his head band? And how would you reason it?
ALSO:
You have to assume that all the prisoners are fairly intelligent and have confidence in the intelligence of their fellow prisoners.
An incorrect guess deems them to imprisonment.
Only one guess can be made by the group.
What colour was his head band? And how would you reason it?
ALSO:
You have to assume that all the prisoners are fairly intelligent and have confidence in the intelligence of their fellow prisoners.
An incorrect guess deems them to imprisonment.
Only one guess can be made by the group.
#6
PopaDopaDo
True Car Nut
...WHITE.
For the 3rd guy to know for sure what he was wearing the other two would both need to be wearing red. He did not speak up so that leaves white-white, or red-white on the first two in line.
So lets consider the 2nd guy in line; what should he see?
Well if the 1st guy was wearing red and knowing the 3rd guy didn't speak up then #2 would know that he is definitely NOT Wearing red thus guarantying that he was wearing white. But since #2 did not speak up #1 must be not be wearing red.
So #1 knows that neither of the others spoke up so he knows that he HAS to be wearing white.
For the 3rd guy to know for sure what he was wearing the other two would both need to be wearing red. He did not speak up so that leaves white-white, or red-white on the first two in line.
So lets consider the 2nd guy in line; what should he see?
Well if the 1st guy was wearing red and knowing the 3rd guy didn't speak up then #2 would know that he is definitely NOT Wearing red thus guarantying that he was wearing white. But since #2 did not speak up #1 must be not be wearing red.
So #1 knows that neither of the others spoke up so he knows that he HAS to be wearing white.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post