Yeah I know I'm bringing this post up from the dead but I couldn't get online until now. I just moved (again) and now I'm in Buffalo, New York. Love it here . . . but a car is pretty much pointless with how good (and cheap) public transportation is.
Anyhow, yes my door seal is supposed to be black, and on my Bonneville (1995) the door seal is visible from inside the car, even when the door is shut.
I'll remember that AC Delco deal. That sounds like a really smart idea. I'm trying not to invest a lot of money in this car since several auto body shops said my strut will be a lost cause in about 3 years.
I'm just gonna resell the wrong door seal and try to get at least some money for it back.
Anyway I hope everyone else'* Bonnie is in good repair.