This guy is a fruit. He keeps complaining about dieng batteris but they NEVER once mentioned looking at or testing the alternator until 4 years later. He was complaining about normal wear and tear on a car that (from what I gather) sits outside all year round and may not be driven for a week at a time or more.
Half his story was how "inconvienent" everything was to do. Most problems were minor but he made them seem like the car was going to blow up every time. He mentioned replaceing just the plugs once. When was there ever a standard tune-up listed?
And the car starter setting off the alarm all the time? Did anyone ever check the passkey bypass? That would be #1 on my list of things.
I will say though, it sounds like the dealership really had no idea what they were doing either. This is a case of two idiots going back and forth...