Rotor Coating loss
#11
DINOSAURUS BOOSTUS
Expert Gearhead
My gauge doesn't have a hard stop...but it does "stop" a little after 10psi.
That'* ok though...got a plan and it'll be slick once I can get moving on it.
Paul... not sure about you blowing oil out your nose... but that coating was there when you bought the car. The only things I've found to degrade the coating is either TB cleaner used without removing the TB from the SC or the meth injection. Honestly..the amount you have missing.....my money is on the injection. TB cleaner is usually a much lesser degree.
That'* ok though...got a plan and it'll be slick once I can get moving on it.
Paul... not sure about you blowing oil out your nose... but that coating was there when you bought the car. The only things I've found to degrade the coating is either TB cleaner used without removing the TB from the SC or the meth injection. Honestly..the amount you have missing.....my money is on the injection. TB cleaner is usually a much lesser degree.
#12
Junior Member
Posts like a Ricer Type-R
Boosty, the earlier clusters do have a hard stop on the gauge (and mine is confirmed). It'* at about 12psi. I hit it daily. Maybe if I hit it hard enough and often enough, I'll wear it off.
Greyhare and I are both injecting also. We were discussing this yesterday at work. In his VW boosted community and in all the research we've BOTH done including memberships on injection forums, we've found this to be somewhat uncommon. And cars that DON'T inject pre-rotor sometimes see this as well.
I have yet to find a documented case where injection is known to have stripped coating. The point is somewhat moot for now, as Paul is now injecting post-rotor. And again, mine may help add to the story depending on what it looks like when it comes out.
Maybe I'll pull it tonight to look.
Greyhare and I are both injecting also. We were discussing this yesterday at work. In his VW boosted community and in all the research we've BOTH done including memberships on injection forums, we've found this to be somewhat uncommon. And cars that DON'T inject pre-rotor sometimes see this as well.
I have yet to find a documented case where injection is known to have stripped coating. The point is somewhat moot for now, as Paul is now injecting post-rotor. And again, mine may help add to the story depending on what it looks like when it comes out.
Maybe I'll pull it tonight to look.
#13
DINOSAURUS BOOSTUS
Expert Gearhead
Originally Posted by willwren
Boosty, the earlier clusters do have a hard stop on the gauge (and mine is confirmed). It'* at about 12psi. I hit it daily. Maybe if I hit it hard enough and often enough, I'll wear it off.
Originally Posted by willwren
Greyhare and I are both injecting also. We were discussing this yesterday at work. In his VW boosted community and in all the research we've BOTH done including memberships on injection forums, we've found this to be somewhat uncommon
Originally Posted by willwren
I have yet to find a documented case where injection is known to have stripped coating. And again, mine may help add to the story depending on what it looks like when it comes out.
#14
Junior Member
Posts like a Ricer Type-R
The most extreme commonly used mix is 50/50 methanol and water.
Keep in mind I've had that in my injection tank all winter. 50/50 mix in a PVC (glued) tank under 60psi. Still holding 60psi. I can say without doubt the tank was unaffected by it.
Try a test. Paul and I both tested our rotors with 100% methanol on the end of the rotor where it doesn't matter much with methanol. I kept it wet with a qtip off and on over a 24 hour period and it didn't even begin to soften.
Keep in mind I've had that in my injection tank all winter. 50/50 mix in a PVC (glued) tank under 60psi. Still holding 60psi. I can say without doubt the tank was unaffected by it.
Try a test. Paul and I both tested our rotors with 100% methanol on the end of the rotor where it doesn't matter much with methanol. I kept it wet with a qtip off and on over a 24 hour period and it didn't even begin to soften.
#15
Senior Member
Certified GM nut
Join Date: May 2005
Location: Wickliffe, Ohio
Posts: 2,155
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by BillBoost37
Paul... not sure about you blowing oil out your nose... but that coating was there when you bought the car. The only things I've found to degrade the coating is either TB cleaner used without removing the TB from the SC or the meth injection. Honestly..the amount you have missing.....my money is on the injection. TB cleaner is usually a much lesser degree.
Bill wouldn't the speed of the water/meth hitting the rotors have more of a effect on the coating then if the water/meth was just static on a rotor for a given period of time?
#16
Junior Member
Posts like a Ricer Type-R
The test we performed was accellerated in two ways:
Concentration doubled.
Exposure time GREATLY increased.
During operation, that methanol has already evaporated. It'* supposed to. Much of the water also. The idea is that as it evaporates, it removes heat from the air around it. The methanol is already in a gas form and most of the water by the time it hits the rotors.
Note that Paul'* was worse on one rotor than the other? I suspect a manufacturing defect. I've seen other rotors do this occasionally without ever injecting anything in them.
Again, my Gen3 will tell the story when it comes off.
Concentration doubled.
Exposure time GREATLY increased.
During operation, that methanol has already evaporated. It'* supposed to. Much of the water also. The idea is that as it evaporates, it removes heat from the air around it. The methanol is already in a gas form and most of the water by the time it hits the rotors.
Note that Paul'* was worse on one rotor than the other? I suspect a manufacturing defect. I've seen other rotors do this occasionally without ever injecting anything in them.
Again, my Gen3 will tell the story when it comes off.
#17
The only things I've found to degrade the coating is either TB cleaner used without removing the TB from the SC or the meth injection. Honestly..the amount you have missing.....my money is on the injection. TB cleaner is usually a much lesser degree.
One interesting observation when inspecting the coatingless rotor is some scuffing on the snout end of the rotor in one location about 1 square inch in size.
I suspect two possibilities. As McGrath stated, it could be velocity/pressure related.
Or it could be the sudden cooling of the injection effect on the hot rotor. Expansion/contraction hence coating delamination. :?
If you look at the edges of the coating, they are not smooth like erosion but look as if the coating simply broke away.