Updated LIM gaskets for S1?
#1
Senior Member
Posts like a Northstar
Thread Starter
Join Date: Apr 2004
Location: Minneapolis, MN
Posts: 566
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Updated LIM gaskets for S1?
I apologize if this has already been covered, I went through pages of threads and didn't find anything relevent. I've searched, but 'lower intake gasket' is (unfortuently) a very common topic.
I know that GM released an updated LIM gasket design for the S2 3800, using steel/aluminum with rubber inserts. Does anybody know if GM also updated the design for the S1 LIM gasket, or am I still stuck using the plastic with rubber inserts?
I know that GM released an updated LIM gasket design for the S2 3800, using steel/aluminum with rubber inserts. Does anybody know if GM also updated the design for the S1 LIM gasket, or am I still stuck using the plastic with rubber inserts?
#2
Junior Member
Posts like a Ricer Type-R
No, they did not change the S1 gaskets. There was no need to. Either the AC Delco or the FelPro gaskets will give you many years of service if properly installed. Particularly if your car isn't converted to DexCool.
#4
DINOSAURUS BOOSTUS
Expert Gearhead
Having S1 or S2 gaskets should not limit which coolant you use.
Dexcool has been found to break down gaskets over time. Which coupled with heat is why we believe has recently led GM to change the design from plastic frame to aluminum frame.
Many S2 owners have flushed and switched to green coolant.
Personally I have flushed and changed over to Prestone Dexcool "approved" coolant which should not be confused with Dexcool.
However with proper maintenance Dexcool should not turn acidic and hurt the gaskets.
Dexcool has been found to break down gaskets over time. Which coupled with heat is why we believe has recently led GM to change the design from plastic frame to aluminum frame.
Many S2 owners have flushed and switched to green coolant.
Personally I have flushed and changed over to Prestone Dexcool "approved" coolant which should not be confused with Dexcool.
However with proper maintenance Dexcool should not turn acidic and hurt the gaskets.
#5
Senior Member
True Car Nut
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Melrose
Posts: 4,596
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Personally I have flushed and changed over to Prestone Dexcool "approved" coolant which should not be confused with Dexcool.
However with proper maintenance Dexcool should not turn acidic and hurt the gaskets.
This is all new to me since I never really ever changed coolant in any of my cars I just drove em till something broke :?
#6
Junior Member
Posts like a Ricer Type-R
jr's3800 has also converted. My personal opinion is that DexCool is the anti-christ.
Have it checked regularly. Othewise change over. Your gaskets will like you for a longer time.
Have it checked regularly. Othewise change over. Your gaskets will like you for a longer time.
#7
DINOSAURUS BOOSTUS
Expert Gearhead
I am very much like you. Learning tons of stuff from the club.
Dexcool has a workable lifespan. What the true amount of time or miles is...I personally don't have that answer. I do know it'* advertised by GM to be something like 5yr 100K. Supposed to be a better coolant. All good things have downsides....ever notice?
I'd plan a 3-4 year or 75K replacement plan on it. With a good flush. Look at some of the pics on the club of peoples under hood. Notice the overflow jug. Dexcool jugs tend to look dirty inside and have rings built up. Both my Dex vehicles have.
The difference between Dex and Prestone "Dex approved" to my knowledge..it'* not the same thing. Therefore probably shouldn't have the same results.
Dexcool has a workable lifespan. What the true amount of time or miles is...I personally don't have that answer. I do know it'* advertised by GM to be something like 5yr 100K. Supposed to be a better coolant. All good things have downsides....ever notice?
I'd plan a 3-4 year or 75K replacement plan on it. With a good flush. Look at some of the pics on the club of peoples under hood. Notice the overflow jug. Dexcool jugs tend to look dirty inside and have rings built up. Both my Dex vehicles have.
The difference between Dex and Prestone "Dex approved" to my knowledge..it'* not the same thing. Therefore probably shouldn't have the same results.
#8
Senior Member
Posts like a Northstar
Thread Starter
Join Date: Apr 2004
Location: Minneapolis, MN
Posts: 566
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Thank you for the replies and the information regarding the S1 gaskets. I've seen S1 gaskets that have collapsed, but it seems to be much less common than the S2 gaskets failing. After all the miles on my original set of gaskets, I'm very interested in seeing just how bad these gaskets are. Especially considering the crap I have already built up in just a couple thousand miles on cyl #1 spark plug since replacing all the plugs.
Regarding the ring around the overflow tank, I've always been led to believe that this is actually caused by leaking lower intake gaskets allowing oil into the coolant, which is transferred into the coolant tank and leads to the sludge buildup in the tank. I've seen this occur with Dex-cool as well as green coolant, which is why I feel that it is not so much a problem with Dex-cool as it is a problem with the vehicle it is used in.
I'm not saying that I support Dex-cool at all, whenever possible I have switched vehicles over to green, both my own vehicles and my customer'* vehicles.
Regarding the ring around the overflow tank, I've always been led to believe that this is actually caused by leaking lower intake gaskets allowing oil into the coolant, which is transferred into the coolant tank and leads to the sludge buildup in the tank. I've seen this occur with Dex-cool as well as green coolant, which is why I feel that it is not so much a problem with Dex-cool as it is a problem with the vehicle it is used in.
I'm not saying that I support Dex-cool at all, whenever possible I have switched vehicles over to green, both my own vehicles and my customer'* vehicles.
#9
DINOSAURUS BOOSTUS
Expert Gearhead
That is saying that every car we see with this Dexcool sludge has an oil leak. No way can I believe that.
To support the theory where is the oil leak in the lower intake manifold gasket? Remember for the oil to get into the coolant, it must be in an area where the oil pressure is higher than 16psi (The pressure of the coolant system.)
To support the theory where is the oil leak in the lower intake manifold gasket? Remember for the oil to get into the coolant, it must be in an area where the oil pressure is higher than 16psi (The pressure of the coolant system.)
#10
Senior Member
Posts like a Northstar
Thread Starter
Join Date: Apr 2004
Location: Minneapolis, MN
Posts: 566
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by BillBoost37
That is saying that every car we see with this Dexcool sludge has an oil leak. No way can I believe that.
And what happens when coolant cools down? It creates a vacuum. Is there a chance that some oil could get sucked into the coolant during this state of vacuum? Yes. Is this the definite reason for oil in the coolant? No. I would be interested in seeing what the sludge in the overflow tank is composed of.