hub/bearing assembly broke apart, stuck in knuckle
#1
Member
Posts like a V-Tak
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2010
Posts: 39
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
hub/bearing assembly broke apart, stuck in knuckle
I ran into a problem swapping the left front wheel bearing/hub assembly, 1995 Park Avenue Ultra.
The axle nut and the three retaining bolts (t-55 torx heads) came off easily. But the hub assembly did not want to separate from the knuckle. I had to use a chisel to wedge the flange loose from the knuckle and also used a 15" crow bar to pry it free. On the inboard side of the hub assembly is the speed sensor. It is housed by a thin steel cover that is pressed onto the back of the three-bolt flange. I found that the speed-sensor housing was rusted to the knuckle and came loose from the rest of the assembly when I finally got (most of!) the assembly apart from the knuckle. So that housing is still stuck in the knuckle, and the inboard side of the removed bearing is uncovered.
My choice seems to be to put it back together and drive it slowly to a shop (the safe choice) or to try to remove that speed sensor housing from the knuckle and continue with the hub assembly replacement.
I don't know that I did anything wrong during the attempted removal. Is this something that happens often? If so what is the usual way out?
Thanks.
The axle nut and the three retaining bolts (t-55 torx heads) came off easily. But the hub assembly did not want to separate from the knuckle. I had to use a chisel to wedge the flange loose from the knuckle and also used a 15" crow bar to pry it free. On the inboard side of the hub assembly is the speed sensor. It is housed by a thin steel cover that is pressed onto the back of the three-bolt flange. I found that the speed-sensor housing was rusted to the knuckle and came loose from the rest of the assembly when I finally got (most of!) the assembly apart from the knuckle. So that housing is still stuck in the knuckle, and the inboard side of the removed bearing is uncovered.
My choice seems to be to put it back together and drive it slowly to a shop (the safe choice) or to try to remove that speed sensor housing from the knuckle and continue with the hub assembly replacement.
I don't know that I did anything wrong during the attempted removal. Is this something that happens often? If so what is the usual way out?
Thanks.
#4
Senior Member
True Car Nut
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: New Lenox, IL
Posts: 2,478
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I ran into a problem swapping the left front wheel bearing/hub assembly, 1995 Park Avenue Ultra.
The axle nut and the three retaining bolts (t-55 torx heads) came off easily. But the hub assembly did not want to separate from the knuckle. I had to use a chisel to wedge the flange loose from the knuckle and also used a 15" crow bar to pry it free. On the inboard side of the hub assembly is the speed sensor. It is housed by a thin steel cover that is pressed onto the back of the three-bolt flange. I found that the speed-sensor housing was rusted to the knuckle and came loose from the rest of the assembly when I finally got (most of!) the assembly apart from the knuckle. So that housing is still stuck in the knuckle, and the inboard side of the removed bearing is uncovered.
My choice seems to be to put it back together and drive it slowly to a shop (the safe choice) or to try to remove that speed sensor housing from the knuckle and continue with the hub assembly replacement.
I don't know that I did anything wrong during the attempted removal. Is this something that happens often? If so what is the usual way out?
Thanks.
The axle nut and the three retaining bolts (t-55 torx heads) came off easily. But the hub assembly did not want to separate from the knuckle. I had to use a chisel to wedge the flange loose from the knuckle and also used a 15" crow bar to pry it free. On the inboard side of the hub assembly is the speed sensor. It is housed by a thin steel cover that is pressed onto the back of the three-bolt flange. I found that the speed-sensor housing was rusted to the knuckle and came loose from the rest of the assembly when I finally got (most of!) the assembly apart from the knuckle. So that housing is still stuck in the knuckle, and the inboard side of the removed bearing is uncovered.
My choice seems to be to put it back together and drive it slowly to a shop (the safe choice) or to try to remove that speed sensor housing from the knuckle and continue with the hub assembly replacement.
I don't know that I did anything wrong during the attempted removal. Is this something that happens often? If so what is the usual way out?
Thanks.
#5
Member
Posts like a V-Tak
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2010
Posts: 39
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
That is reassuring. I was thinking of something similar. I could use a little cutoff wheel on a Dremel tool to gash the thin metal then grab onto the edges with pliers and pull it out. Does that sound okay?
I wonder whether there is any worry about damaging the recess where the assembly fits into the knuckle---I mean the surface that the thin metal is rusted to, in case I gouge the knuckle a little with the cutoff wheel. I don't know why they make it such a close fit.
I wonder whether there is any worry about damaging the recess where the assembly fits into the knuckle---I mean the surface that the thin metal is rusted to, in case I gouge the knuckle a little with the cutoff wheel. I don't know why they make it such a close fit.
#6
Member
Posts like a V-Tak
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2010
Posts: 39
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
XTREME
Ha ha ... you forgot to mention that it is a five minute job.
Best may be to pound it inward at the top, using a chisel or drift or screwdriver. It is ring shaped, so pounding it in at the top makes it skewed or cocked so that it sticks out on the bottom. Then it can be grabbed with pliers and pulled out.
I did use the Dremel tool to cut it in one place. That may have weakened it considerably.
I have a clear knuckle now. Thanks for the courage ...
Ha ha ... you forgot to mention that it is a five minute job.
Best may be to pound it inward at the top, using a chisel or drift or screwdriver. It is ring shaped, so pounding it in at the top makes it skewed or cocked so that it sticks out on the bottom. Then it can be grabbed with pliers and pulled out.
I did use the Dremel tool to cut it in one place. That may have weakened it considerably.
I have a clear knuckle now. Thanks for the courage ...
#7
Member
Posts like a V-Tak
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2010
Posts: 39
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
related question ...
The machined surface of the knuckle that contacts the hub/bearing flange has some patches of rust maybe a quarter millimeter thick. Will it hurt anything to leave that rust there?
The machined surface of the knuckle that contacts the hub/bearing flange has some patches of rust maybe a quarter millimeter thick. Will it hurt anything to leave that rust there?
#8
Senior Member
True Car Nut
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: New Lenox, IL
Posts: 2,478
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
haha, yeah it really is a 5 minute job, and you can even use a screwdriver. I pretty much did exactly what you did when it happened to me. I was confused for a little while till I realized what happened.
I would sand it down real quick with a coarse grit and grease it up before putting the new one in to prevent this from happening if you ever have to replace the hub again, but if you don't have that option, you can just get it in there and go through this process again if you ever have to do it again. Its not a big deal if the knuckle gets nicked or scratched in a few places so long as the hub can bolt to it properly.
I would sand it down real quick with a coarse grit and grease it up before putting the new one in to prevent this from happening if you ever have to replace the hub again, but if you don't have that option, you can just get it in there and go through this process again if you ever have to do it again. Its not a big deal if the knuckle gets nicked or scratched in a few places so long as the hub can bolt to it properly.
#9
Retired Senior Admin
Expert Gearhead
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Sheboygan Wisconsin
Posts: 29,661
Likes: 0
Received 28 Likes
on
24 Posts
Look at this write up, does this help any? https://www.gmforum.com/mechanical-134/wheel-hub-replacement-290447/
#10
Member
Posts like a V-Tak
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2010
Posts: 39
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Dan-- Nice idea to use those short bolts and nuts to press the bearing out of the knuckle. Wish I'd seen that sooner. But I don't think it would help with the problem of the bearing assembly being rusted into the knuckle and coming apart during removal, which turned out to be not much of a problem anyway if you are replacing the assembly.