Endless P0171- some new hope
#1
Senior Member
Posts like a Northstar
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: Valley Forge, PA
Posts: 598
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Endless P0171- some new hope
The '98 SSEi.
P0171- is a lean burn in the bank. more air than gas when firing.
The story without end.
Months ago, extra air appeared on my boost gauge. At idle. -7.5 instead of pegged at -10. Been steadily checking, spraying carb cleaner, and replacing all vacuum lines and connectors over months. Finally started getting intermittent appearance of P0171. It usually comes on when I kick it over, or shortly thereafter. Plus it occurs when the engine is cold. I don't believe it has ever happened after the car is at temperature.
New development.
Finally fed up, took it to a dealer (that hurt, having to do that). They said no vacuum leaks, but it needed a new fuel pump. 39psi. $800, thanks, but I'll take a shot at it. Put in a Delphi pump, which looked exactly like the one I took out. Also replaced the screen/bag. (my fuel filter is 3 months old, and had no effect on the problem, before or after)
Afterwards, turned the key to ON to fire up the pump. Got out of the car to find the fuel pressure gauge at 45 psi. Better, but not quite. The spec for '96-'99 is 48-55psi. But then I thought of something. So I stood over the gauge, while I had the wife turn the key to the ON position. All within 5 seconds or so, the gauge jumped to 52-54 psi, and i got a hissing sound somewhere around where the MAP sensor stuff is, and (I think) the EVAP purge valve.The psi dropped to 45.
I can repeat this continuously, over and over again. And the same thing happens. I never noticed it before, because I didn't jump out of the car fast enough.
It gets even better. If I leave the gauge on for an hour or so, with the car turned off, the fuel pressure drops to 10psi.
Notes:
The battery cables are not clean, they are virtually new and cleaned, with particular care fixed to the engine block and starter.
During this long period, I measured my charge circuit as fine, but discovered the battery was a swelled pig. Replaced it with a maximum cranker. I haven't tested the alternator separately. And don't know how to find out how much current is reaching the fuel pump. When i use the a/c or power windows or brakes, the boost gauge moves even higher.
I have had 3 OEM gas caps on this thing. Never have I gotten the sweet sound of good tank pressure, when I removed the cap to fill the tank.
There has never been a performance interrupt problem. No uneven idling, no misses, no stalls, and the fuel pressure blows right into and through the pressure zone on throttle.
Sorry this is long, but I wanted to put out as much info as possible.
Qs
- Fuel system isn't my strong point, particularly how the EVAP system works with it to get rid of the vapors. What'* going on here?
- Chilton'* tells me to check a few items, if the rail loses pressure when the car is off. The first thing is the "check valve". I saw no valve on the entire pump assembly, only the pulsator. Is that the check valve?
- If I paint the car black, will it rid me of this neverending "White curse" episode?
ANY thoughts or help will be appreciated. After this, my last task before mods start is the SC coupler and snout. As long as i have been trying to figure this out, they may fall off before i get to them.
Thanks.
charlie
P0171- is a lean burn in the bank. more air than gas when firing.
The story without end.
Months ago, extra air appeared on my boost gauge. At idle. -7.5 instead of pegged at -10. Been steadily checking, spraying carb cleaner, and replacing all vacuum lines and connectors over months. Finally started getting intermittent appearance of P0171. It usually comes on when I kick it over, or shortly thereafter. Plus it occurs when the engine is cold. I don't believe it has ever happened after the car is at temperature.
New development.
Finally fed up, took it to a dealer (that hurt, having to do that). They said no vacuum leaks, but it needed a new fuel pump. 39psi. $800, thanks, but I'll take a shot at it. Put in a Delphi pump, which looked exactly like the one I took out. Also replaced the screen/bag. (my fuel filter is 3 months old, and had no effect on the problem, before or after)
Afterwards, turned the key to ON to fire up the pump. Got out of the car to find the fuel pressure gauge at 45 psi. Better, but not quite. The spec for '96-'99 is 48-55psi. But then I thought of something. So I stood over the gauge, while I had the wife turn the key to the ON position. All within 5 seconds or so, the gauge jumped to 52-54 psi, and i got a hissing sound somewhere around where the MAP sensor stuff is, and (I think) the EVAP purge valve.The psi dropped to 45.
I can repeat this continuously, over and over again. And the same thing happens. I never noticed it before, because I didn't jump out of the car fast enough.
It gets even better. If I leave the gauge on for an hour or so, with the car turned off, the fuel pressure drops to 10psi.
Notes:
The battery cables are not clean, they are virtually new and cleaned, with particular care fixed to the engine block and starter.
During this long period, I measured my charge circuit as fine, but discovered the battery was a swelled pig. Replaced it with a maximum cranker. I haven't tested the alternator separately. And don't know how to find out how much current is reaching the fuel pump. When i use the a/c or power windows or brakes, the boost gauge moves even higher.
I have had 3 OEM gas caps on this thing. Never have I gotten the sweet sound of good tank pressure, when I removed the cap to fill the tank.
There has never been a performance interrupt problem. No uneven idling, no misses, no stalls, and the fuel pressure blows right into and through the pressure zone on throttle.
Sorry this is long, but I wanted to put out as much info as possible.
Qs
- Fuel system isn't my strong point, particularly how the EVAP system works with it to get rid of the vapors. What'* going on here?
- Chilton'* tells me to check a few items, if the rail loses pressure when the car is off. The first thing is the "check valve". I saw no valve on the entire pump assembly, only the pulsator. Is that the check valve?
- If I paint the car black, will it rid me of this neverending "White curse" episode?
ANY thoughts or help will be appreciated. After this, my last task before mods start is the SC coupler and snout. As long as i have been trying to figure this out, they may fall off before i get to them.
Thanks.
charlie
#2
Senior Member
Posts like a 4 Banger
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Columbus Ohio
Posts: 109
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I just spoke to a Pontiac Dealer'* Service Dept. and was told that the correct fuel pressure on a 96 SE is 40.5 to 47 PSI. Seems like the 98'* & up had a higher spec
#3
Senior Member
Posts like a 4 Banger
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Columbus Ohio
Posts: 109
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I think the bleed down in pressure is fairly normal too. I have problem with the p0171 code too. I'm intrigued with the possibilty of the Evap system. I've not heard of this before but it gives me something else to check.
#4
Senior Member
Posts like a Northstar
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: Valley Forge, PA
Posts: 598
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
1986-1995 41-47psi, except 1995 L36
1995 L36 and 1996-1999 48-55 psi
This is only for your initial ignition state ie key ON, engine OFF. When you actually kick the engine over, the fuel psi should drop anywhere from 3-10 psi, due to the lower manifold pressure.
From there it'* a mental crapshoot for me. Temperature, barometric pressure, the Idle air control (IAC), and a host of things get involved which contribute to action by the regulator.
Hoping against hope, what my system is doing wrong is this..... it powers up with key ON to 52-54. But it should stay there. Instead I hear that purge/leak (whatever) and the pressure drops, but to the normal idle operation range. So it'll kick over and run right, but the PCM is seeing a low fuel pressure/lean burn for a turnover, and/or low pressure/lean burn for a cold engine idle. I don't remember ever getting the P0171 on a start or run where the engine was at operating temperature.
That may sound like I know what'* going on, but i don't. The EVAP vacuum circuit is in this somewhere.
P0171 is a not-too-bad in an L36. But a lean burn in an L67 that you want to mod, is a KR bad dream, with a chipped piston waiting down the road.
#5
Senior Member
Posts like a Northstar
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: Valley Forge, PA
Posts: 598
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
And the ground cable from the positive terminal to the ground on the base of your engine is by far the most important one to clean and clean the connection post.It'* a bugger to get to on a '96, but ya have to do it. You'll save yourself a world of future pain. An 18 inch 13mm(i think) wrench does the trick, or anything you can rig up like that, if you are tool poor like me.
#6
DINOSAURUS BOOSTUS
Expert Gearhead
Hi guys...
If you search on my name and that code you'll find lots of info. I feel like I bought the code in the past.
Having fought it a few times, here'* the "usual suspects" that I've found.
Fuel pressure. 40+ is fine. The spec from 96+ is 48-52 but it'* not that important. I've yet to find 48+ with all new components.
Corrosion inside the battery cable. If your terminals at the battery were nasty and you cleaned them, look where the strands head into the sheath, if they are corroded that'* a possibility. Swapping cables out for new is the only way to fix that issue.
Grounds, when doing grounds, clean the ones on each front fender (by battery and horns), clean the one ground on the back side of the block, down behind the oil filter. (Easiest to access through the wheel well).
Vaccum connectors: remove the airbox and replace the vacuum connection rubber chunks of hose at the charcoal canister. Check that the hose from the evap soleniod marked "CAN" does indeed go to the canister. Check the U bend on the other side hose going to the throttle body (this is a commonly cracked piece). Injector O -rings could be a potential, but carb clean testing would pick this up.
Throttle body gasket, check for vac leaks
EGR tube. There'* a tube from the EGR that heads under the throttle body, this is a flimsy piece of tinfoil. These crack right at the end where the holding piece pushes on it to keep it seated. To know if this is an issue, remove the tube from the EGR/LIM and hold up to light inspecting closely. These cracks can be tough to find.
Maf sensor, it'* one of the first things the FSM tells you to check. Car can run fine etc but if it'* dirty etc, clean it up. While the FSM checks it first, I check it last unless there'* a code. Reason being is the test is to unplug it. This test can give you a false positive because it makes the engine run off tables instead of real airflow data. This can richen the mixture and mask the code. Then you get a new maf and still have the code, that'* no fun.
Start off with those things and see if that works for you.
If you search on my name and that code you'll find lots of info. I feel like I bought the code in the past.
Having fought it a few times, here'* the "usual suspects" that I've found.
Fuel pressure. 40+ is fine. The spec from 96+ is 48-52 but it'* not that important. I've yet to find 48+ with all new components.
Corrosion inside the battery cable. If your terminals at the battery were nasty and you cleaned them, look where the strands head into the sheath, if they are corroded that'* a possibility. Swapping cables out for new is the only way to fix that issue.
Grounds, when doing grounds, clean the ones on each front fender (by battery and horns), clean the one ground on the back side of the block, down behind the oil filter. (Easiest to access through the wheel well).
Vaccum connectors: remove the airbox and replace the vacuum connection rubber chunks of hose at the charcoal canister. Check that the hose from the evap soleniod marked "CAN" does indeed go to the canister. Check the U bend on the other side hose going to the throttle body (this is a commonly cracked piece). Injector O -rings could be a potential, but carb clean testing would pick this up.
Throttle body gasket, check for vac leaks
EGR tube. There'* a tube from the EGR that heads under the throttle body, this is a flimsy piece of tinfoil. These crack right at the end where the holding piece pushes on it to keep it seated. To know if this is an issue, remove the tube from the EGR/LIM and hold up to light inspecting closely. These cracks can be tough to find.
Maf sensor, it'* one of the first things the FSM tells you to check. Car can run fine etc but if it'* dirty etc, clean it up. While the FSM checks it first, I check it last unless there'* a code. Reason being is the test is to unplug it. This test can give you a false positive because it makes the engine run off tables instead of real airflow data. This can richen the mixture and mask the code. Then you get a new maf and still have the code, that'* no fun.
Start off with those things and see if that works for you.
#7
Senior Member
Posts like a Northstar
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: Valley Forge, PA
Posts: 598
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Hi guys...
(snip)
Fuel pressure. 40+ is fine. The spec from 96+ is 48-52 but it'* not that important. I've yet to find 48+ with all new components.
(snip)
(snip)
EGR tube. There'* a tube from the EGR that heads under the throttle body, this is a flimsy piece of tinfoil. These crack right at the end where the holding piece pushes on it to keep it seated. To know if this is an issue, remove the tube from the EGR/LIM and hold up to light inspecting closely. These cracks can be tough to find.
(snip)
i was wondering about the fuel pressure. there have been guys with pressure 10-15psi low, before any problem presented itself. If I can kick the car over and the pressure responds properly in synch with the throttle, what else would I want from the fuel supply..
My cables are the cleanest parts on my car. Over the past few years, I know we've seen an incredibly wide range of problems resulting from corroded battery cables. Over the past 6+ months, I have virtually cleaned my entire engine and connecting parts with carb/choke cleaner or brake cleaner, looking for leaks..
But today, here'* the question...
If I reach around the crosspipe, and spray brake cleaner on the EGR line, and where it goes into the LM.... and the exhaust becomes a dense acrid white smoke....
Do ya think that means anything?
I haven't pulled it yet, so i don't know what it is made out of. But like you said, it looks like aluminum. Aluminum is resistant to radiant heat, not conductive heat like it would get from laying on the crosspipe.
Thanks bigtime for your help.
<all>PS, FYI, I used brake cleaner because I was out of carb cleaner. Do this sparingly. Many brake cleaners, when combusted are highly catalytic (acidic), and rough on gasket edges,sensors etc. Plus, if you take a nice huff of the exhaust, you will likely get a headache for a few hrs.
#8
DINOSAURUS BOOSTUS
Expert Gearhead
Well CM.. it'* been my experience that I was always unable to get anything in that area for good testing. If your exhaust changes, then something is occuring, no doubt there.
I'd pull out the ole 13mm and check it out. There'* a good chance you'll be LBO'less soon.
If you get the tube out w/o pulling the TB, .... that'* a mastered art.
I'd pull out the ole 13mm and check it out. There'* a good chance you'll be LBO'less soon.
If you get the tube out w/o pulling the TB, .... that'* a mastered art.
#9
Senior Member
Posts like a Northstar
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: Valley Forge, PA
Posts: 598
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Well CM.. it'* been my experience that I was always unable to get anything in that area for good testing. If your exhaust changes, then something is occuring, no doubt there.
I'd pull out the ole 13mm and check it out. There'* a good chance you'll be LBO'less soon.
If you get the tube out w/o pulling the TB, .... that'* a mastered art.
I'd pull out the ole 13mm and check it out. There'* a good chance you'll be LBO'less soon.
If you get the tube out w/o pulling the TB, .... that'* a mastered art.
Yeah. That area is a big intersection of suspects. under area of the TB, the EGR pipe, and the LIM.
I'm goin' out now and carefully put the TB and the rest back on. But I'm not so cocked sure it'* the EGR anymore. The LIM gasket is overdue. I was waiting til i had the time to do the */C, put new bearings in the snout, and replace the jingling coupler.
We'll see.
The story might not be over, but i know where it'* generally located.
#10
DINOSAURUS BOOSTUS
Expert Gearhead
I've actually been successful w/o taking off the TB. But I had seen a bunch and had the shallow swivel socket for the job. If you suspect a leak under the TB, it could be the SC to LIM or TB to SC gasket as well.